Appellate Court Halts Goregaon Society's Wing-Wise Maintenance Hike, Orders Flat-Wise Calculation
The Maharashtra State Co-operative Appellate Court has stayed a Goregaon society's revised maintenance charges that raised two D-wing flats' bills nearly fourfold, holding that model bye-laws require charges to be calculated per flat, not per wing.
The Maharashtra State Co-operative Appellate Court, presided over by S.S. Sapatnekar, has directed Aurum Tower Co-operative Housing Society on S.V. Road, Goregaon West, to keep in abeyance a maintenance revision that sharply raised charges for two flats. The ruling was reported on November 19, 2026. The appeal was filed by members Ramawadh Devnandan Jayaswal and his son Nishit Jayaswal after Co-operative Court No. 4, Mumbai, refused them interim relief on February 23, 2026.
What the dispute was about
The society has four wings: A (82 flats), B (55), C (76) and D (2). Under a resolution of the annual general meeting held on March 27, 2022, and a circular applying revised charges from July 1, 2022, costs were apportioned wing by wing. As a result, the two D-wing flats, previously charged Rs 7,867 each, were billed Rs 27,166 and Rs 29,266. The court's comparison showed per-flat charges of about Rs 2,529 in A wing, Rs 2,643 in B wing and Rs 2,357 in C wing, against Rs 21,180 per flat in D wing under the disputed method.
The society argued that D wing had its own water and electricity connections and a separate lift. The court rejected this, noting the wing was built by the developer as per the approved plan. It also found that the society produced no later general body resolution adopting the revised charges and no evidence of approval at a September 30, 2018 AGM.
The court's directions
The court held that Model Bye-laws 65, 66 and 67, which govern how a society levies its service and maintenance charges, require charges to be calculated per flat or unit, not per wing. It ordered the society to recalculate the charges through an independent chartered accountant, consider members' objections, and apply the revised rates uniformly across all four wings. The case number was not stated in the report.
What this means for housing societies
- Splitting common expenses wing by wing, so that a small wing bears a disproportionate share, can be challenged as contrary to the model bye-laws.
- Maintenance revisions should be approved by the general body and properly minuted; a society may be asked to produce the resolution that adopts the new rates.
- Separate meters or a separate lift in one wing does not by itself justify a different charging basis when the layout follows the approved building plan.
- Using an independent chartered accountant to work out charges, and inviting member objections, helps a committee defend its calculations.
Managing committees that apportion costs by wing or building should review their current billing method against the bye-laws they have adopted and, where needed, place a corrected, flat-wise calculation before the general body.
For informational purposes
This news summary is based on publicly available information and is intended for general awareness only. It does not constitute legal advice. For guidance specific to your society, consult a qualified legal advisor or housing society consultant familiar with your situation.
Want the deeper picture?
Our blog covers the legal context, member rights, and practical steps behind every CHS issue in Maharashtra.
Browse all articles